There were at least three John Arnolds living in Winchester in the early 15th century, but the main outlines of the career of the Hampshire MP are quite clear.
The elder John Arnold, like his younger namesake, was also involved in the cloth trade which flourished in and around Winchester, and it was probably he who in 1401-2 had been assessed for alnage on a small quantity of cloth sold in the city. The properties let to him by Beaufort in 1406 included, for the large annual rent of 40 marks, three local mills, two of which were for fulling. Arnold’s powerful position as bailiff of the Soke enabled him to interfere with the workings of one of the city’s own mills, and a year later the fullers of Winchester complained that he ‘impedivit et interrupit cursum aque, preponens distruccionem et deterioracionen dicti molendi’, thus harming their industry. He was evidently on better terms later with at least one of their number, for he acted as executor of a draper named John Moule.
Arnold was clearly in demand as an executor, and is known to have been asked to act as such by, among others, Dr. Thomas Ayleward (parson of Havant and himself one of Bishop Wykeham’s executors), Thomas Lavington (rector of Meon Stoke), and Thomas, 2nd Lord West. The last, when he made his will on 1 Aug. 1415, left Arnold £6 13s.4d., but after West’s death at sea in the following year he, in conjunction with his fellows, refused to undertake the administration of the will. Arnold attended the Hampshire elections to the Parliaments of 1414 (Nov.) (when Lewis John, a close associate of Bishop Beaufort’s cousin, Thomas Chaucer, was elected), 1419 and 1420.
The full extent of Arnold’s property in and near Winchester is not known, though he certainly owned some buildings in Kingsgate Street, and leased from St. Swithun’s priory a lime-kiln and fishery. In 1431 his premises in the city were valued at £4 p.a. Although by then he had ceased to act as bailiff of the Soke, his commendable services to Cardinal Beaufort were by no means forgotten. In January 1433 the cardinal granted him and his son John the office of apparitor-general of the diocese for term of their lives in survivorship. Arnold senior did not occupy it for long: both he and his widow were dead by June that year.
