Karr’s father, Thomas, was one of the wealthiest merchants in early fifteenth-century York, having gained the freedom of the city in 1406. A draper by trade, he supplied cloth to Durham priory among others, but made his fortune by acting as a middleman between the wool growers and weavers, fullers and dyers. In his will he made bequests to six weavers and one, John Staynoney, was named as his executor. Although he appears to have disposed of his property before his death, he passed on a considerable amount of cash, some £336, to his son. He also played a full role in the government of the city, in 1422-3 serving as chamberlain and five years later as sheriff. He subsequently became a member of the council of 24 and by June 1433, when he witnessed the parliamentary election, he had joined the ranks of the aldermen.
John is first heard of in 1423-4, when as a child, along with his parents he was admitted into the city’s prestigious guild of Corpus Christi, but it took a further ten years before he gained the freedom of York by patrimony.
In the penultimate week of his mayoralty, on 20 Jan. 1449, Karr was present in the council chamber to witness his own election to the Parliament summoned to assemble at Westminster the following month. He was returned alongside another wealthy York merchant, John Thirsk*.
Following his return from Parliament, Karr’s role in civic government is hard to trace. He witnessed the parliamentary elections of October 1449, but not that of the following year and he was not recorded as having attended any council meetings. It seems likely that the letters patent exempting him for life from civic office were now put into effect. A possible explanation for his reluctance to serve further in the government of the city is that his business affairs frequently required his absence. By the late 1440s Karr was one of the leading northern merchants of the Calais staple. Lacunae in the customs records for Kingston-upon-Hull prevent a reconstruction of the scale of his dealings in wool, but by then he was renting a messuage there in Hull Street, perhaps a warehouse for his wool or a place from which to conduct his trading ventures.
Despite the letters patent exempting him from office and an evident reluctance to serve, in February 1456 Karr again accepted election as mayor of York. The circumstances of his election to the mayoralty are not recorded and his mayoral year appears to have passed without incident. In June he was appointed to a commission to deliver York gaol, but no ad hoc commissions are recorded. He was, however, still owed money by the city chamberlains five years later for expenses incurred while in office.
When Karr made his will on 6 Nov. 1487, he was an old man, almost certainly in his mid 70s. He asked to be buried in his parish church of St. Sampson next to Joan, his late wife, and made provision his funeral there, specifying that 13 poor men, clad in white gowns, should attend his corpse. Karr was clearly concerned to ease his soul’s passage through purgatory and his will was almost entirely concerned with elaborate and specific instructions for prayers and masses. He made bequests to over a dozen religious houses and hospitals, including the abbeys of St. Mary, York, and Riveaulx, and the priories of Appleton, Clementhorp, Hull, North Ferriby and Watton, with specific instructions concerning the nature and number of masses to be said in each. Karr gave two gold rings, set with a diamond and a ruby, to hang on the image of the Virgin and Holy Child in York Minster in return for prayers there, as well as 4d. to every parish priest in the city and its suburbs. He also remembered the city’s poor: as well as alms to the prisoners in the various prisons, he made bequests of cash to provide for the marriage of 15 ‘pore madyns well disposed to mariage’, for 50 beds and sets of linen to be distributed among the impoverished, and a further £20 for married couples living in poverty within the city. Of the £145 of cash bequests made by Karr in his will, £125 was given to religious institutions or in alms. Several named servants received gifts of cash and silverware, but the most curious bequest was that of a ‘payr of spectacles of sylver and gylted and a bonet that was sumtyme the Bishoppis of Hereforth’ to the abbot of St. Mary’s. These had presumably belonged to John Stanbury (d.1474), Henry VI’s former confessor and councillor, but how they had come into Karr’s possession remains obscure. No mention was made of any property, apart from the ‘place that I won in and my other place in Fynkelstrete’, and these, like the remainder of his goods and chattels, were to be disposed of by his executors for the benefit of his soul. His executors, a chantry priest in St. Sampson’s and the parson of St. John, Micklegate, York, were granted probate on 20 Apr. 1488.
