Carey was a first cousin of Elizabeth I through his grandfather’s marriage to Mary Boleyn, the queen’s aunt. His father, one of Elizabeth’s most trusted courtiers, was created Baron Hunsdon in 1559, and the family remained in favour during the following reign, when his brother Robert became Prince Charles’s governor. Robert was rewarded in 1626 with the earldom of Monmouth, while Carey’s nephew, the 4th Lord Hunsdon, became earl of Dover in the following year.
Carey apparently remained at Court during the following decade, but the minor grants of royal land that he procured failed to offset his expenses. By 1596 he was reduced to selling the property that he had acquired through his first marriage. However, following an appeal for help to Sir Robert Cecil†, he received the keepership of Hyde Park, and by 1598 he had become an esquire of the body.
Carey lost his principal Court role upon the queen’s death, but in February 1603 he had also procured the lesser post of knight harbinger, which he retained under the new regime. In April 1604, with the assistance of Sir Robert Cecil, now Lord Cecil, he obtained 1,000 marks as compensation for an earlier Crown lease that had proved defective.
Carey is not known to have stood in the 1604 parliamentary elections. However, in January 1606 he was returned in a by-election at Calne, some six miles from Dauntsey, conceivably again with the earl of Hertford’s backing. His main objective in re-entering the Commons was doubtless to support the bill to restore his stepson Henry Danvers to the estates forfeited in 1601. Although he was not recorded as speaking in the measure’s favour, he was named to its committee on 13 March. The bill received the royal assent at the end of the session.
Carey left no trace on the records of the 1606-7 session. However, during the first session of 1610 he was named to consider bills concerned with the estates of a Huntingdonshire gentleman, and the liability of entailed lands to debt payments (22 Feb., 30 June). He also acted on 2 May as a teller in a vote concerning the Commons’ latest message to the Lords about the Great Contract. Ostensibly he sided with many Members’ preference for a limited bargain relating only to the Crown’s powers of wardship, but in the absence of any speeches, his precise attitude towards the Contract is unclear. On 2 July he was granted privilege in relation to the arrest of one of his servants.
Carey was still knight harbinger in October 1614, but vacated the post shortly afterwards. Despite losing his formal role at Court, he was resident in the nearby parish of St. Martin-in-the-Fields in 1625, and ceased to serve as a Wiltshire magistrate around that time.
