Kighley was the fourth generation of his family to live at South Littleton, three miles north-east of Evesham.
Kighley probably owed his election for Evesham in 1604 to the role he played in securing the borough its charter earlier that year. Although returned without incident, he became embroiled in a dispute over the remaining seat, which was coveted by Sir Francis Egioke, the brother of Kighley’s first wife. Indeed, Egioke had Kighley indicted for riot, presumably for supporting Sir Thomas Bigg*.
In the 1604 session Kighley was appointed to four committees. The first was to consider the motion of Sir Francis Hastings concerning religion (16 April). The remainder were legislative, concerning the bill against brokers (16 June), a measure to assign money for the Household (18 June), and the bill concerning the attorneys and clerks of King’s Bench and Common Pleas (22 June 1604).
In the last months of his life Kighley, whose lands were by now held by trustees, was in serious financial difficulties. He declined to make a will, but instead left his personal estate to Sir Francis Egioke by deed of gift.
